Plato IntelligenceEssays on Plato

Life & Times

Plato’s Travel and Exposure to Different Philosophies

Weathered stone statue of a bearded man in a draped robe, seated before a sandstone wall

In short. After Socrates died, Plato went to Megara, reportedly Cyrene and Egypt, then Italy and three times to Syracuse. Where he went, what he met and how we know.

After the execution of Socrates in 399 BC, Plato left Athens. Ancient sources have him go first to Megara, then, by later report, to Cyrene in North Africa and to Egypt, and then to southern Italy, where he met the Pythagoreans. Around 388/387 BC, at about forty, he reached Syracuse in Sicily, and he went back twice, around 367 and 361 BC, in a failed attempt to make its young ruler a philosopher. The Italian and Sicilian journeys are well attested; Cyrene and Egypt are tradition; and the popular idea that he studied Persian or Indian philosophy has no ancient support.

The travels mattered to his philosophy in two ways the evidence can support: they brought him into close contact with Pythagorean mathematics, and the Sicilian visits tested his belief that philosophers should rule. Most details come from Diogenes Laertius, who wrote more than five centuries after Plato’s death, and from the Seventh Letter, whose authenticity is disputed, so the account below separates what is well attested from what is tradition.

Where did Plato travel?

Place Main source How well attested
Megara Diogenes Laertius III.6 Reported; plausible
Cyrene Diogenes Laertius III.6 Late report; uncertain
Southern Italy Seventh Letter 326b, 338c; Diogenes Laertius III.6 Well attested
Syracuse, Sicily (three visits) Seventh Letter; Diogenes Laertius III.18–23 Well attested in outline
Egypt Cicero, De Finibus V.87; Strabo; Diogenes Laertius III.6 Ancient tradition; not certain
Persia and the Magi Diogenes Laertius III.7 Intended, not carried out
India, Asia Minor none No evidence

Megara and the Socratic circle

Diogenes Laertius (III.6) says that after Socrates’ death Plato, then twenty-eight, withdrew to Megara, where Euclides, another follower of Socrates, was based. Plato’s Theaetetus (142a–143c) is framed as a conversation written down by Euclides of Megara, which at least shows that Plato knew him. A stay in Megara kept him inside the Socratic circle rather than exposing him to a foreign tradition.

Cyrene and the mathematician Theodorus

Diogenes (III.6) says Plato went on to Cyrene to see the mathematician Theodorus. Plato never confirms the trip, but Theodorus appears in the Theaetetus, proving that certain square roots are irrational (147d). Whether or not Plato went to Cyrene, he learned from mathematicians connected with it, and mathematics became central to the Academy.

Southern Italy and the Pythagoreans

The Italian journey is the best attested and the most important for his philosophy. In the Seventh Letter Plato says he went to Italy and Sicily when he was about forty (324a, 326b), and the letter shows him on close terms with Archytas of Tarentum, a Pythagorean mathematician and statesman (338c–d), who later helped get him safely out of Syracuse (350a–b). Diogenes Laertius (III.6) adds that Plato went to see the Pythagoreans Philolaus and Eurytus, which is plausible but less secure.

Aristotle, who studied at the Academy, says in the Metaphysics (987a29–b14) that Plato’s philosophy followed the Pythagoreans in many respects, with features of its own. The debt shows in the immortality and rebirth of the soul, the importance of number and harmony, and mathematics as training for philosophers in the Republic. He may have met some Pythagorean ideas in Athens first, so exactly what he learned in Italy is uncertain. See Pythagorean mathematics and Plato.

Why did Plato go to Syracuse?

Plato visited Syracuse three times (Seventh Letter; Diogenes Laertius III.18–23):

  1. Around 388/387 BC, at the court of the tyrant Dionysius I. Diogenes says the first trip was to see the island and the craters of Etna. Plato met Dion, the tyrant’s brother-in-law, who became his friend and follower. Later tradition says Dionysius had Plato sold as a slave on Aegina; that is a late anecdote not found in the Seventh Letter. See why Plato was enslaved.
  2. Around 367 BC, after Dionysius I died. Dion urged Plato to come and educate the young Dionysius II as a philosopher. The court turned against Dion, who was exiled, and Plato left with nothing achieved.
  3. Around 361 BC, at Dionysius II’s renewed invitation, with Archytas and his friends urging him to go. Plato was kept at court against his will and got away with the help of Archytas (Seventh Letter 350a–b).

The effect on his thought is easy to overstate. The Seventh Letter (324a–326b) says that his conviction that cities will be well governed only when philosophers rule had already formed in Athens, after the Thirty Tyrants and the death of Socrates, before he first sailed west. Sicily gave him a test of that idea: a close view of a tyrant’s court, a personal commitment to Dion, and the discovery that educating a ruler is far harder than describing one. Readers often connect this with the portrait of the tyrant in the Republic and with the more practical politics of the Laws, but that connection is an inference. See why Plato was disillusioned.

Did Plato go to Egypt?

Possibly. Cicero (De Finibus V.87), Strabo and later Diogenes Laertius (III.6) say he did, and Strabo claims he was shown where Plato had stayed at Heliopolis. The Seventh Letter does not mention it, and no source close to Plato confirms it. Plato’s dialogues show respect for Egypt: in the Timaeus (21e–25d) an Egyptian priest tells Solon that the Greeks are always children, and in the Laws he praises the stability of Egyptian art (656d–657a). These passages use Egypt as a symbol of antiquity. Greek writers such as Herodotus had already described Egypt at length, so they do not prove a visit, and nothing in his philosophy is demonstrably Egyptian in origin.

Did Plato study Persian or Eastern philosophy?

No ancient source says he did. Diogenes Laertius (III.7) says Plato intended to visit the Magi, the Persian priestly class, but was stopped by the wars in Asia: the one ancient report about Persia describes a trip that did not happen. Plato knew a good deal about Persia, as the history of Cyrus and Darius in the Laws (III, 693c–698a) shows, but that material was available in Herodotus and Xenophon. Athens itself was a trading port with resident foreigners, so he had no need to travel to hear foreign ideas.

The “Eastern influence” claim grew up long after his death:

  • Ancient admirers of foreign wisdom. The Platonist Numenius (2nd century AD) is reported to have asked what Plato was but Moses speaking Attic Greek (fr. 8, quoted by Clement of Alexandria, Stromateis I.150). No evidence supports the idea that Plato used the Hebrew scriptures.
  • Neoplatonist curiosity. Porphyry (Life of Plotinus 3) says Plotinus joined a Roman campaign against Persia in AD 242–244 hoping to learn Persian and Indian philosophy. That is a fact about Plotinus, not Plato.
  • Modern comparison. Scholars have noted parallels between Plato’s account of reincarnation and Indian thought. Parallels are not transmission: reincarnation already existed in Greek Orphic and Pythagorean circles, the sources Plato most plausibly used.

Which philosophies did Plato actually meet?

Most of them at home in Athens, and the rest in Greek-speaking Italy and Sicily: Socrates and his circle; the Heraclitean doctrine of flux through Cratylus; the Eleatic arguments of Parmenides; the Pythagoreans; and the Sophists, whom he opposed. Each is covered in what influenced Plato, and his own schooling in the key influences on Plato’s education.

The better-documented cross-cultural story runs the other way. Plato’s thought spread through the Hellenistic and Roman world and was later known in Arabic, mostly through summaries and paraphrases: al-Farabi summarised the Laws, and Ibn Rushd (Averroes) wrote a commentary on the Republic.

Common questions

How many times did Plato go to Sicily?

Three times, around 388/387, 367 and 361 BC, all to the court of Syracuse.

How long did Plato travel?

The sources give no total. The journeys fall between Socrates’ death in 399 BC and the first Sicilian visit around 388/387 BC, with the two later Sicilian trips in his sixties. After that he stayed at the Academy until his death around 348/347 BC.

Did Plato’s travels influence the Academy?

Probably. On the usual chronology he founded the Academy soon after returning from his first visit to Italy and Sicily, and its emphasis on mathematics fits what he had learned from Theodorus and the Pythagoreans. See what institution Plato founded.

Keep reading

More essays in Life & Times →