Plato IntelligenceEssays on Plato

Life & Times

How did Plato’s Travel Influence His Philosophy?

Ancient marble sculpture representing How did Plato's Travel Influence His Philosophy?

In short. Plato's travels to Megara, Italy, Sicily and (reportedly) Cyrene and Egypt left traces in his thought, mainly in mathematics and politics. Here is the evidence.

Plato’s travels influenced his philosophy mainly in two ways that the evidence can support: through Pythagorean mathematics and philosophy, which he met in southern Italy, and through politics, because his repeated trips to Sicily gave him first-hand experience of a tyranny and a failed attempt to educate a ruler. The common claim that he absorbed Persian, Indian or other “Eastern” philosophy on his journeys has no good evidence behind it. Most details of his itinerary come from late biographers and from the Seventh Letter, whose authenticity is disputed, so the picture below separates what is well attested from what is tradition.

Where did Plato actually travel?

Plato’s dialogues almost never speak about his own life, so the itinerary has to be pieced together from the Seventh Letter, Diogenes Laertius (who wrote more than five centuries after Plato’s death) and a few later writers.

Place Main source How well attested
Megara Diogenes Laertius III.6 Reported; plausible
Cyrene Diogenes Laertius III.6 Reported by late sources; uncertain
Southern Italy Seventh Letter 326b, 338c; Diogenes Laertius III.6 Well attested
Syracuse, Sicily (three visits) Seventh Letter; Diogenes Laertius III.18–23 Well attested in outline
Egypt Cicero, De Finibus V.87; Diogenes Laertius III.6 Ancient tradition; plausible, not certain
Persia and the Magi Diogenes Laertius III.7 Intended, not carried out
India, Asia Minor none No evidence

Megara and the Socratic circle

Diogenes Laertius (III.6) says that after the execution of Socrates in 399 BC, Plato withdrew to Megara, where Euclides, another follower of Socrates, was based. Plato’s own dialogue the Theaetetus (142a–143c) is framed as a conversation recorded by Euclides of Megara, which at least shows that Plato knew him. A stay in Megara would have kept Plato inside the Socratic circle rather than exposing him to a foreign tradition.

Cyrene and the mathematician Theodorus

Diogenes (III.6) says Plato went on to Cyrene in North Africa to hear the mathematician Theodorus. This is reported by later writers and not confirmed by Plato. What is certain is that Theodorus appears in the Theaetetus, where he is shown proving that the square roots of certain numbers are irrational (147d). Whether or not Plato visited Cyrene, he learned mathematics from people connected with it, and mathematics is one of the habits of thought that the Academy later made central.

Southern Italy and the Pythagoreans

The Italian trip is the best attested and the most important philosophically. In the Seventh Letter Plato says he went to Italy and Sicily when he was about forty (324a, 326b), and the letter shows him on close terms with Archytas of Tarentum, a Pythagorean mathematician and statesman (338c–d). Archytas later helped to extricate Plato from Syracuse in his last visit (350a–b). Diogenes Laertius (III.6) adds that Plato studied with the Pythagoreans Philolaus and Eurytus, which is plausible but less secure.

Aristotle, who knew the Academy from within, says in the Metaphysics (987a29–b14) that Plato’s philosophy in many respects followed the Pythagoreans, though with its own features, and he makes a point of describing Plato’s Forms in relation to Pythagorean numbers. Pythagorean themes also run through Plato’s dialogues: the immortality and reincarnation of the soul, the importance of number and harmony, and the use of mathematics as a training for philosophers in the Republic. Plato’s debt to the Pythagoreans is a strong case for something he learned from contact abroad, although he may also have met Pythagorean ideas in Athens, so the exact point of the debt is uncertain. Our essay on Pythagorean mathematics and Plato covers the philosophy in more detail.

Sicily and the problem of philosophers and rulers

Plato went to Syracuse three times: around 388/387 BC under the tyrant Dionysius I, and around 367 and 361 BC under his son Dionysius II (Seventh Letter; Diogenes Laertius III.18–23). The Seventh Letter says that his hope was to turn the young ruler towards philosophy, working with Dion, a relative by marriage of Dionysius I, and that it failed, leaving him in danger on the last visit.

The effect on his thought is easy to overstate. The Seventh Letter (324a–326b) says that his conviction that cities will not be well governed until philosophers rule had already formed in Athens, after the Thirty Tyrants and the trial of Socrates, before he first sailed west. What Sicily gave him was a test of that idea: direct experience of tyrannical court life, a personal commitment to Dion, and the practical discovery that educating a ruler is far harder than describing one. Readers often connect these experiences to the portrait of the tyrant in the Republic and to the political advice in the Laws and the letters, but the connection is an inference, not something Plato states.

The ancient tradition also adds a story about Plato being sold as a slave at Aegina after a quarrel with Dionysius I. That is a late anecdote and is discussed separately in why Plato was enslaved.

Egypt: tradition and what Plato wrote about it

Cicero (De Finibus V.87; On the Republic I.16), Strabo (XVII.1.29) and later Diogenes Laertius (III.6) say that Plato travelled to Egypt. It is not mentioned in the Seventh Letter. The idea is plausible, because Greek intellectuals of the period are reported to have visited Egypt, but it cannot be confirmed. Plato’s own writing shows respect for Egypt: in the Timaeus (21e–25d) an Egyptian priest tells Solon that the Greeks are always children; in the Laws he praises the stability of Egyptian art (656d–657a) and their way of teaching arithmetic to children through games (819a–c). These passages prove that Plato knew about Egypt, which Greek writers such as Herodotus had already described, but not that he went there. Nothing in his philosophy is demonstrably Egyptian in origin.

Did Plato travel to Persia, India or Asia Minor?

There is no good evidence that he did. Diogenes Laertius (III.7) says that Plato intended to visit the Magi, the Persian priestly class, but was prevented by the wars in Asia. That sentence is the only ancient statement on the subject, and it says the trip did not take place. Nothing ancient places Plato in India, and nothing places him in Asia Minor as a student. His knowledge of Persia, including the account of its kings in the Laws, is consistent with what Greek historians such as Herodotus and Xenophon had written, and does not require a visit. Claims that Persian justice, North African mysticism or Indian thought shaped his ideas are later speculation. They are discussed in Plato’s travel and exposure to different philosophies.

What was the real influence?

The best-supported conclusion is modest. Travel put Plato in contact with Pythagorean philosophy and mathematics, and it drew him into the politics of Syracuse, which tested and hardened his views on rule. Other formative influences came from home: Socrates above all, but also the Heraclitean ideas he met through Cratylus and the Eleatic argument of Parmenides, and the Athenian political crisis of 404–399 BC. See what inspired Plato for the wider picture, and the list of sourced facts about his life for how each travel claim is supported.

Keep reading

More essays in Life & Times →