Plato IntelligenceEssays on Plato

Afterlife

Why Was Plato Famous?

Black-and-white image of a bearded philosopher in robes, carved like a statue, reading an open book

In short. Plato is famous for the Theory of Forms, the Cave, the Republic and the Academy, and because he is how we know Socrates. Seven reasons, each explained.

Plato is famous for seven things: his writings are the oldest body of Western philosophy to survive complete; he gave philosophy its first great theory, the Theory of Forms; he wrote its most famous image, the Allegory of the Cave; his Republic founded political philosophy; he is the reason we know Socrates at all; he founded the Academy and taught Aristotle; and his critics, starting with Aristotle, kept arguing with him for two and a half thousand years.

This essay takes each reason in turn. For his life story (family, travels, death) see who Plato was; for the sourced biographical details, see 24 facts about Plato.

1. His Work Survived Complete

Most early Greek philosophers survive only in fragments quoted by later writers. Plato is the exception: around thirty-five dialogues and a set of letters come down under his name, and essentially all of it survives. That alone made him the fixed point every later philosopher had to read. The full list is in Plato’s complete works.

He also wrote unusually well. The dialogues are drama, with characters, settings and jokes, which is a large part of why they kept being copied and read when drier treatises were lost. Plato himself was suspicious of writing, which makes his survival through it an irony he would have noticed.

2. He Invented the Theory of Forms

Plato argued that the changing world we see is not the most real thing there is. Behind it stand the Forms: perfect, unchanging realities such as Justice, Beauty and Equality, which particular things only imitate. Knowledge, on this view, is knowledge of the Forms, and the senses give at best opinion about their copies. It is the first full answer in Western thought to what reality is and what we can know about it, and every later theory of universals is in some way a reply to it. See also Platonic idealism and his theory of recollection.

3. He Wrote the Allegory of the Cave

Prisoners chained in a cave mistake shadows on a wall for reality; one is freed, climbs into the sunlight, and is resented when he comes back to tell the others. Few images in philosophy are as widely known, and it carries the whole theory in one scene: the Forms, education as a painful turning towards the light, and the philosopher’s awkward place in society. See how to interpret the Allegory of the Cave.

4. The Republic Founded Political Philosophy

The Republic asks what justice is and answers by designing a city: three classes mirroring the three parts of the soul, ruled by a philosopher king who knows the Good. Along the way it proposes that women can be rulers, that the guardians should hold no private property, and that democracy slides towards tyranny. Few of its proposals were adopted, but almost every later work of political philosophy argues with it.

5. He Is How We Know Socrates

Socrates wrote nothing. Almost everything we picture when we think of him (the questioning in the marketplace, the claim to know nothing, the trial and the hemlock) comes from Plato’s dialogues, with Xenophon and Aristophanes as thinner witnesses. Plato made Socrates the hero of nearly all his works, so his own fame and his teacher’s are bound together, and separating them is still one of the hardest problems in ancient philosophy. More on how Socrates shaped Plato’s philosophy and on the Socratic method in the dialogues.

6. He Founded the Academy and Taught Aristotle

Around 387 BC Plato set up a school in the grove of Academus outside Athens, teaching mathematics and dialectic alongside philosophy. It is often called the first university in the West, and in some form it carried on for centuries. Its most famous student, Aristotle, stayed for about twenty years, so the two most influential philosophers of antiquity came out of the same room.

7. His Critics Kept Him Famous

Plato has never lacked opponents, and the arguments with him are part of his fame:

  • Aristotle rejected Forms that exist apart from things, and the split between the two became one of the organising divisions of Western thought.
  • Democrats have read the Republic as a blueprint for rule by an unaccountable elite; it is one of the few ancient books still argued over as live politics.
  • On women, the Republic lets women be guardians and rulers, yet calls them generally weaker than men, and readers still debate how far his view goes.
  • Practical readers object that he diagnoses problems better than he solves them. The dialogues often end without an answer, by design.

A thinker people still bother to refute is a thinker still being read.

Still Famous Today

Plato’s influence did not stop with the Greeks. Through Plotinus and Augustine his ideas shaped Christian theology; his distinction between appearance and reality sits under modern arguments about truth; and the phrase “platonic love”, coined much later from the Symposium, is in everyday speech. Alfred North Whitehead’s remark that European philosophy “consists of a series of footnotes to Plato” is an exaggeration, but it is the kind people only make about one philosopher.

For where he came from and how his life unfolded, read who Plato was. For why his ideas spread so widely after his death, see why Plato was so influential.

Keep reading

More essays in Afterlife →